Managers lack 'soft skills'
January 4 2003 -
A recent study of study of 35,000 Australian and New Zealand managers found
that managers regularly deny responsibility,
withdraw from threatening situations or people, resort to
aggressive tactics to get their way, stick to established rules and procedures - and
are characterized by a fear of failure.
"These results are not surprising when we look at the popularity of
people management, communication, negotiation and conflict
management programs for executives not only in Australia, but
around the world", says Dr Anne Lytle of the Australian Graduate
School of Management (AGSM). "There is a growing awareness of the
importance of these 'soft' skills, which are in reality the most
difficult and challenging skills for adults with ingrained patterns
of behaviour to learn.
"We also know from research done in other cultural contexts that
authoritarian management behaviour is more pervasive than
facilitative or participative management behaviour. We also know
that most employees, at least in the West, prefer and are more
satisfied when their managers have a participative style. This
mismatch implies that organisations that want to retain good talent
should monitor, measure, and work to improve the self-awareness and
emotional intelligence of their managers.
"Australians have a unique set of cultural values and norms on
which management behaviour is based. Australians, for example,
negotiate very differently from Americans. While Americans shy
away from few topics, Australians generally prefer to avoid rather
than discuss conflicts when possible and to address problematic
issues in more informal contexts (like on the golf course or in the
pub).
"Almost all human beings in the face of stress engage in either
'flight' or 'fight'. If I cannot avoid, then I am likely to act
aggressively when cornered," says Dr Lytle. " In the workplace,
however, these two responses are often inappropriate. It takes a
great deal of self-awareness and training for a manager to
regularly respond more constructively".
The study of 35,000 Australian and New Zealand managers was conducted by
the organisational development company Human Synergistics.